6 min video with captions · one-page job aid · short quiz
Job aid
Make it impossible, or catch it at once
Everyone makes mistakes. Design the process; don't blame the person. "Be more careful" is not a device.
Type
What it means
Test
🛡 Prevention
The mistake can't be made at all
Could the wrong thing happen at all? No → prevention
⚠ Detection
The mistake can be made, but it's signalled at once, before it does harm
Yes, but you'd know straight away → detection
Prevention is stronger. Detection is still worth having, as close to the mistake as you can put it.
Sorted examples: prevention: keyed connectors · a form that accepts only valid formats · a currency drop-down · currency filled in from a saved record · enterer can't approve their own payment · an offset fixture pin · feeding-tube connectors that can't fit IV lines. Detection: a digital task card that can't close with a step unsigned · a logging torque wrench · a tool count at the shadow board · a payee-name check · dual control · end-of-day reconciliation · a fastener-count sensor · wristband and medication scan · a pick scan · a carton weight check.
Find where to start: the risk table
Step
How it could fail
Likelihood (L)
Severity (S)
Score = L × S
…
…
1 rare · 3 sometimes · 5 often
1 minor, fixed at once · 3 rework or delay · 5 safety, legal or major financial harm
1–25
Start with the three highest scores.
Choose devices: the ranking grid. Find at least two devices for each top step. Place each by cost (low · medium · high) and effectiveness (1–5). Aim for the top left: low cost, high effect. Prefer prevention; where you can't prevent, detect early. A device supports the required checks; it never replaces them.
Watch out for: "be more careful" as a fix · alarms nobody acts on · removing a required check because a device exists · scoring severity by annoyance rather than impact.
Offset fixture pin (P) · fastener-count sensor stops the line (D) (supplemental example)
✚ Healthcare
n/a
Feeding-tube connectors that can't fit IV lines (P) · wristband and medication scan (D) (supplemental example)
📦 Logistics
n/a
Pick scan must match the order (D) · carton weight check, over 5% checked (D) (supplemental example)
All examples are fictional.
Quiz
Answer each question first; the answer and why open after you choose or press “Show the answer”. Nothing is saved or sent.
Pass mark: 4 of 5 questions, and Q3 must reach 8 of 10. Q5 counts as correct at 4 of 5 rubric points.
Q1 · Airline MRO · Tools left behind
Scenario: At a fictional line station, "a tool left in the work area" scores 3 × 5 = 15 (FOD: foreign object debris, a loose item that can damage an aircraft). The team can't find a way to make leaving a tool physically impossible.
Question: Which pair of devices is best, and does the release still need its checks?
Answer: B
Why:
A) "Be careful" is not a device, and nothing replaces a required check.
B) ✓ Both are low-cost detection (effectiveness 4) that catch a missing tool before release. When a mistake can't be designed out, detect it before harm. Devices support the release sign-off; they never replace it.
C) These devices fit the connector step, not tools.
D) A device never replaces a required check like the duplicate inspection.
Q2 · Banking/Services · The three highest risks
Scenario: A fictional bank's payments team scores six steps (likelihood L and severity S, each 1–5): enter beneficiary details 4 × 4 · choose a currency 3 × 4 · approve a high-value payment 2 × 5 · enter the payment date 3 × 2 · attach supporting documents 3 × 2 · reconcile at end of day 2 × 3.
Question: Which three steps are the highest risk?
Answer: A
Why:
A) ✓ Multiply L × S: 16, 12, 10, 6, 6, 6. The three highest are where you start.
B) Likelihood alone ignores how serious each failure is.
C) Severity alone ignores how often each failure happens.
D) Scoring exists to focus effort; the top three come first.
Q3 · Classification exercise (mixed industries)
Task: Mark each device P (prevention: the mistake can't be made) or D (detection: it can be made, but is signalled at once).
Keyed connectors that physically can't mate with the wrong socket
A payee-name check that flags a mismatch before submission
A currency drop-down with no free text
A tool count against the shadow board before release
Feeding-tube connectors that can't connect to IV lines
A carton weighed and compared with its expected weight
An offset fixture pin, so a housing can't be loaded backwards
A wristband and medication barcode scan that flags a mismatch
A system rule that whoever enters a payment can't approve it
A sensor that stops the line if fewer than 6 fasteners are driven
Answer key (1 point each; pass at 8 of 10): 1 P · 2 D · 3 P · 4 D · 5 P · 6 D · 7 P · 8 D · 9 P · 10 D.
Q4 · Manufacturing · Transfer question
Scenario: On a fictional assembly line, two devices are proposed. An offset fixture pin (a peg in the holding jig, placed off-centre) means a housing can't be loaded backwards. A sensor counts the fasteners (screws) and stops the line if fewer than 6 are driven.
Question: Which is prevention, and why is it usually preferred?
Answer: B
Why:
A) The sensor detects: fewer than 6 fasteners can still be driven; it's caught at once.
B) ✓ The pin makes the mistake impossible. Prevention is usually preferred because no defect is made, so there's no rework or chance of missing it. The sensor is still worth having.
C) Stopping a bad part leaving is detection's job; prevention means the mistake can't be made.
D) A second person checking is detection too, and it relies on attention; designed devices are stronger.
Why this transfers: manufacturing isn't planned for M9 in the video, and the scenario explains its terms (fixture pin, fasteners). A learner who can ask "could the wrong thing happen at all?" can answer without factory knowledge.
Q5 · Design exercise (learner's choice)
Task: Use a six-step process from your own work, or this fictional one: booking a training course for a team member: choose the course · check the dates against the team calendar · enter the attendee's details · get the manager's approval · pay the fee · send the joining instructions. Score each step (L × S), pick the top three, and propose two devices for each, placed on a cost/effectiveness grid.
Rubric (1 point each; pass at 4 of 5):
#
Point awarded when…
1
Every step has L and S (1–5) and the scores are multiplied correctly
2
The top three are the three highest scores
3
Each top step has at least two devices
4
Each device is correctly labelled prevention or detection
5
The ranking is justified by cost and effectiveness, prevention preferred, and no required check is removed
All examples are fictional.
Cookies on InLine Ops. We'd like to use optional analytics cookies to see how the site is used and improve it. They're only set if you accept. Read more about cookies
ACADEMY · IN PRODUCTION
The Academy opens soon
We use your email only to tell you about this. See our Privacy Policy.