ACADEMY · FREE MODULE 9 OF 11

M9 · Mistake-Proofing (Poka-Yoke)

6 min video with captions · one-page job aid · short quiz

Job aid

Make it impossible, or catch it at once

Everyone makes mistakes. Design the process; don't blame the person. "Be more careful" is not a device.

Type What it means Test
🛡 Prevention The mistake can't be made at all Could the wrong thing happen at all? No → prevention
⚠ Detection The mistake can be made, but it's signalled at once, before it does harm Yes, but you'd know straight away → detection

Prevention is stronger. Detection is still worth having, as close to the mistake as you can put it.

Sorted examples: prevention: keyed connectors · a form that accepts only valid formats · a currency drop-down · currency filled in from a saved record · enterer can't approve their own payment · an offset fixture pin · feeding-tube connectors that can't fit IV lines. Detection: a digital task card that can't close with a step unsigned · a logging torque wrench · a tool count at the shadow board · a payee-name check · dual control · end-of-day reconciliation · a fastener-count sensor · wristband and medication scan · a pick scan · a carton weight check.

Find where to start: the risk table

Step How it could fail Likelihood (L) Severity (S) Score = L × S
… … 1 rare · 3 sometimes · 5 often 1 minor, fixed at once · 3 rework or delay · 5 safety, legal or major financial harm 1–25

Start with the three highest scores.

Choose devices: the ranking grid. Find at least two devices for each top step. Place each by cost (low · medium · high) and effectiveness (1–5). Aim for the top left: low cost, high effect. Prefer prevention; where you can't prevent, detect early. A device supports the required checks; it never replaces them.

Watch out for: "be more careful" as a fix · alarms nobody acts on · removing a required check because a device exists · scoring severity by annoyance rather than impact.

Examples

Industry Top risks (L × S) Two devices each (type · cost · effect)
✈ Airline MRO Task-card step missed 16 · connectors swapped 15 · tool left behind 15 Keyed connectors (P · high · 5), colour bands (D · low · 3) · digital task card (D · medium · 5), records review (D · low · 3) · tool count (D · low · 4), tool tags (D · low · 4). The duplicate inspection and release sign-off stay
🏦 Banking/Services Beneficiary keyed wrong 16 · wrong currency 12 · error approved unchecked 10 Format validation (P · low · 4), payee-name check (D · low · 4) · drop-down (P · low · 3), saved currency (P · low · 4) · dual control (D · medium · 4), enterer can't approve (P · low · 5)
⚙ Manufacturing n/a Offset fixture pin (P) · fastener-count sensor stops the line (D) (supplemental example)
✚ Healthcare n/a Feeding-tube connectors that can't fit IV lines (P) · wristband and medication scan (D) (supplemental example)
📦 Logistics n/a Pick scan must match the order (D) · carton weight check, over 5% checked (D) (supplemental example)

All examples are fictional.

Quiz

Answer each question first; the answer and why open after you choose or press “Show the answer”. Nothing is saved or sent.

Pass mark: 4 of 5 questions, and Q3 must reach 8 of 10. Q5 counts as correct at 4 of 5 rubric points.

Q1 · Airline MRO · Tools left behind

Scenario: At a fictional line station, "a tool left in the work area" scores 3 × 5 = 15 (FOD: foreign object debris, a loose item that can damage an aircraft). The team can't find a way to make leaving a tool physically impossible.

Question: Which pair of devices is best, and does the release still need its checks?

Q2 · Banking/Services · The three highest risks

Scenario: A fictional bank's payments team scores six steps (likelihood L and severity S, each 1–5): enter beneficiary details 4 × 4 · choose a currency 3 × 4 · approve a high-value payment 2 × 5 · enter the payment date 3 × 2 · attach supporting documents 3 × 2 · reconcile at end of day 2 × 3.

Question: Which three steps are the highest risk?

Q3 · Classification exercise (mixed industries)

Task: Mark each device P (prevention: the mistake can't be made) or D (detection: it can be made, but is signalled at once).

  1. Keyed connectors that physically can't mate with the wrong socket
  2. A payee-name check that flags a mismatch before submission
  3. A currency drop-down with no free text
  4. A tool count against the shadow board before release
  5. Feeding-tube connectors that can't connect to IV lines
  6. A carton weighed and compared with its expected weight
  7. An offset fixture pin, so a housing can't be loaded backwards
  8. A wristband and medication barcode scan that flags a mismatch
  9. A system rule that whoever enters a payment can't approve it
  10. A sensor that stops the line if fewer than 6 fasteners are driven

Q4 · Manufacturing · Transfer question

Scenario: On a fictional assembly line, two devices are proposed. An offset fixture pin (a peg in the holding jig, placed off-centre) means a housing can't be loaded backwards. A sensor counts the fasteners (screws) and stops the line if fewer than 6 are driven.

Question: Which is prevention, and why is it usually preferred?

Q5 · Design exercise (learner's choice)

Task: Use a six-step process from your own work, or this fictional one: booking a training course for a team member: choose the course · check the dates against the team calendar · enter the attendee's details · get the manager's approval · pay the fee · send the joining instructions. Score each step (L × S), pick the top three, and propose two devices for each, placed on a cost/effectiveness grid.

All examples are fictional.